The best 5 Ice Cream Makers Compared in 2025 – Which One Is Right for You?

As the demand for homemade frozen treats rises, selecting the right ice cream machine becomes essential. Whether you're a home enthusiast or a business owner, this guide will help you navigate the top options available in 2025.

1. Ninja Ice Cream Maker

Best For: Home users seeking versatility and ease of use.

Key Features:

Seven one-touch programs for various frozen treats.

Compact design suitable for home kitchens.

Easy to clean with dishwasher-safe parts.

Pros:

Versatile functionality for ice cream, gelato, sorbet, and more.

User-friendly interface.

Quick preparation time.

Cons:

Requires pre-freezing of ingredients.

Limited batch size.

Price: Approximately $349.99

2. Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

Best For: Users desiring professional-quality ice cream at home.

Key Features:

Built-in compressor for continuous use.

Separate paddles for ice cream and gelato.

1.5-quart capacity.

Pros:

No need to pre-freeze the bowl.

Produces smooth and creamy textures.

Durable construction.

Cons:

Higher price point.

Larger footprint on countertops.

Price: Approximately $299.95

3. Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker

Best For: Tech-savvy users seeking customizable settings.

Key Features:

12 hardness settings for different frozen desserts.

Pre-cool and keep-cool functions.

1.5-quart capacity.

Pros:

Highly customizable texture settings.

Automatic hardness sensing.

Stylish stainless-steel design.

Cons:

Premium price tag.

It can be complex for beginners.

Price: Approximately $499.95

4. GSEICE BJK288S 2500W Commercial Ice Cream Maker

Best For: Small businesses and commercial use.

Key Features:

Dual 2.1-gallon hoppers with a 2500W compressor.

Produces up to 8.4 gallons per hour.

LCD panel with pre-cooling and self-cleaning functions.

Pros:

High output suitable for commercial settings.

Three flavor options with an efficient puffing system.

Durable and reliable performance.

Cons:

Significant investment required.

Larger size necessitates ample space.

Price: Approximately $2,399.99

5. Whynter ICM-200LS 2.1 Quart Automatic Compressor Ice Cream Maker

Best For: Home users seeking professional results.

Key Features:

Built-in compressor for continuous use.

2.1-quart capacity.

Stainless steel housing with LCD control panel.

Pros:

No pre-freezing required.

Produces high-quality ice cream consistently.

User-friendly operation.

Cons:

Heavier and bulkier than some home models.

Slightly higher price range.

Price: Approximately $319.00

Comparison Table

Ice Cream Maker	Best For	Capacity	Price	Notable Feature
Ninja CREAM	Home versatility	Varies	$349.99	Multiple programs
Cuisinart ICE-100	Professional home use	1.5 qt	$299.95	Built-in compressor
Breville Smart Scoop	Custom settings	1.5 qt	$499.95	12 hardness levels
GSEICE BJK288S	Commercial use	8.4 gal/hr	$2,399.99	High output
Whynter ICM-200LS	Home professional	2.1 qt	$319.00	No pre-freezing

Conclusion

Selecting the right ice cream maker depends on your specific needs and budget:

For home users seeking versatility and ease, the Ninja CREAMi offers a range of options at an affordable price.

For those desiring professional-quality results at home, both the Cuisinart ICE-100 and the Whynter ICM-200LS provide excellent performance without the need for pre-freezing.

Tech enthusiasts will appreciate the Breville Smart Scoop's customizable settings.

Small business owners should consider the GSEICE BJK288S for its high output and reliability.

Evaluate your requirements, space, and budget to make the best choice for your ice cream-making adventures in 2025.